Hmmm....well I definitely think that several conservative theologians also are predisposed against certain supernatural phenomena as well. Perhaps just of a different sort. I love the dialogue that quotes like this generate!
I am not sure which supernatural phenomena you refer to, but the truth is all of us come to the table with "enormous predispositions." I believe it will always be this way, for humans are born with a large amount of faith, but it is our free will that determines where that faith will be grounded.